It's a lie to say that pictures never lie, as our readers and viewers know all too well.

A reader called us Tuesday morning, accusing us of having plopped President Clinton's mug smack in the middle of an AP photo of King Hussein's funeral procession. We hadn't done that, of course, but the reader hung up before we could get a word in and tell him that. The AP and The Journal Times both have photo ethics codes that forbid such photo maniplulation, but the reader, who was evidently savy enough to know that it wouldn't have been that hard to manipulate the photo, doesn't know or care about our ethics codes.


President Clinton walks behind the casket of King Hussein of Jordan as they depart the Raghdan Palace enroute to the Royal Guards Mosque in Amman, Jordan, Monday, Feb. 8, 1999. A reader called Tuesday morning, and accused us of electronically inserting Clinton into the scene. Photo by Doug Mills/ Associated Press (c) 1999 (with permission)

 

As a photo editor I don't have to look too far to answer the question of where readers get the notion that we might mislead them with our photos.

  Last week the Associated Press published the what may be the most bizarre caption correction to have ever moved on the wires. The AP corrected the spelling of the late Wiarton Willie the Groundhog's name, but more significantly, they also had to explain that their photographer had been lied to when he took a photo that purported to show the recently departed creature in his coffin. Apparently the real late Willie had been dead so long, and was so badly decomposed when his handlers tried to roust him for Groundhog Day, that they used an older stuffed groundhog as a stand-in for their photo of Willie's wake.

It's not uncommon for our subjects to suggest we stage a photo if we can't get the real McCoy. They don't always understand our refusal to accept their gracious offer. Willie's handlers probably thought they were doing the right thing when they invited photographers to cover the phony funeral, but they just added to the perception that what you see in the morning paper or on television may not bear much relation to reality.

A crew from a Milwaukee TV station didn't help the cause, either, Monday, when they were covering a press conference to announce that the Imaginarium, a proposed children's museum in Racine, had secured a $2 million loan, and would begin construction after four years of planning. The media-savy museum folks rounded up a group of children and had them hold up large letter spelling I-M-A-G-I-N-A-R-I-U-M in order. Up went the "I," then "M," and so on. Whooops...the TV guys blew their shot. "Could you do that again?" they asked.

Last year I watched another station's reporter tell school children to do the "Packer-rena," a local take-off on the Macarena, danced to the tune of a Green Bay Packers anthem. The kids were otherwise occupied, but that didn't bother the reporter who decided that the truth be damned, it'd make a great visual to get the kids up and dancing for the cameras. The camera doesn't lie.

Really???

Ours don't, but try telling that to some of our readers.

Mark Hertzberg
< hertz@wi.net >
Director of Photography
Journal Times
Racine, Wisconsin
Other journals by Mark Hertzberg
363 May 2000 Three short topics
361 April 27, 2000 It's a moment frozen forever
359 April 18, 2000 I'm glad I wasn't working
346 February 18, 2000 Fatal Fire
343 January 28, 2000 Suicide By Cop
340 December 28, 1999 Four Minute Justice
338 December 11, 1999 In 1/125th of a second
336 December 4, 1999 Day in Court
332 Is Photojournalism Dead?Mark Hertzberg On the flip side, though, many newspapers that have made a 180-degree change have changed for the better rather than for the worse
325 October 10, 1999 Oh, the people you meet
324 September 29, 1999 It was an innocent question from a high school clerk
309 July 23, 1999 I didn't mind Jerome Vine spit at me twice
307 July 21, 1999 "What have you done? What have you dragged us into?"
303 July 17, 1999 If your mother says she loves you, check it out
292 June 23, 1999 You Never Know
283 May 17, 1999 Epilogue to May 4, 1999
276 May 4, 1999 David Raymond Segura, Sr. walked out of the Racine County Jail to the cheers and hugs of his family
272 April 25, 1999 Littleton. Burlington.
265 April 18, 1999 "I can't believe I'm being paid to have fun. "
261 April 15, 1999 It was the first time...
257 March 26, 1999 The Supreme Court isn't sure I should have been able to shoot one of the most dramatic pictures I've ever taken.
248 March 13, 1999 I got nauseous on the job today...
247 March 12, 1999 The prosecution's case
246 March 12, 1999

Sidebar: One of the most difficult issues for us to consider

239 March 1, 1999 That's your guy.
222 February 11, 1999 It's a lie to say that pictures never lie, as our readers and viewers know all too well.
215 February 4, 1999 Remember report cards?
213 February 1, 1999 I saw something horrifying and shocking this week
198 January 8, 1999 Damn, it's hard to cover news stories when you know the people involved in them, and when you have to put aside personal feelings to get the story.
192 December, 1998 This journal is a tribute to you, the reader
180 November 29, 1998 Abortion. That's the only word you have to mention in any conversation, and emotions are aroused , so imagine what it's like trying to make newsroom decisions about how to cover the issue. That's where we found ourselves Thursday morning at the Racine Journal Times.
178 November 22, 1998 We Interrupt This Broadcast
176 November 18, 1998 Our big story last week, indeed perhaps our biggest of the year, was a story about something that DIDN'T happen.
175 November 16, 1998 Did We Overact?
174 November 8, 1998 Wednesday was the day the yellow smiley face from that big chain of stores from Arkansas frowned at me.
171 November 3, 1998 Monday Morning, Post Gore
170 November 2, 1998 I'm so excited, I won't be able to sleep tonight
158 October 12, 1998 It was one of those days when an assignment was as much fun as opening birthday presents.
157 October 10, 1998 He's a cop...
150 September 21, 1998 A friend of mine calls it the ultimate form of channel surfing. .
146 September 11, 1998 ...sometimes we can have a positive effect on people's lives even when some readers think we are raking them over the coals. .
138 August 28, 1998 Sometimes the last thing a photographer wants to see is a camera.
120 July 25, 1998 They say that in England you are innocent until proven guilty; in France you are guilty until proven innocent; and in America you are innocent until the next edition of the newspaper flies off the presses or the evening news comes on.
111 July 12, 1998 We joke that today's newspaper is tomorrow's fish wrap. But for many people, our work lives on beyond just that day's paper.
109 July 7, 1998 Delgado, who sat in his orange county jail jumpsuit, had tears streaming down his face as he listened to the charges being read the day after his nine-month old son died on a hot summer day, strapped in his car seat, in the backseat of Delgado's broiling Dodge Omni
101 June 23, 1998 We've never shown the readers this sunset view of the city before...if all goes well, it'll stretch across Wednesday morning's front page. Today is Monday, though, and they first have to get through Tuesday's newspaper.
100 June 22, 1998 Last week I had the tables turned on me
87 June 4, 1998 ..none of those pictures would have been published without his help.
82 May 29, 1998 Today was one of those days in which you hit the lows and the highs.
78 May 26, 1998 You never know where a pair of dirty socks will take you
73 May 17, 1998 I no longer have to hide under semi-trailer trucks to shoot news pictures of major industries..
67 April 24, 1998 Stop the Presses
63 April 19, 1998 Sign of Discontent
43 March 24, 1998 Humphrey Bogart, move over.
42 March 23, 1998 In the end, only one photo was important...
32 February 27, 1998 My work has now been published in a new media...on a picket sign
28 February 24, 1998

Journalists usually love a good juicy story. I'm in the middle of covering one I hate. Part 3

February 23, 1998 Journalists usually love a good juicy story. I'm in the middle of covering one I hate. Part 2

 

22 February 20, 1998 Journalists usually love a good juicy story. I'm in the middle of covering one I hate. Part 1
13 February 4, 1998 (9:24 AM) It was a situation where one has to shoot pictures first, and ask questions later Update: To Mark's February 4 posting
7 January 27, 1998 The viewfinder in our cameras is dark for the split second we shoot our photos...
5 January 23, 1998 Just what is news?
3 January 19, 1998 An 83-year-old reader called me this morning, in tears. .
 
Contributor since 1998
 
   


home |about this documentary | the journals | search this site | reviews & talkback

Behind the Viewfinder - A Year in the Life of Photojournalism
http://www.digitalstoryteller.com/YITL
This site is protected by United States Copyright Laws
Website Design Copyright 1998, 1999, 2000 F.R."Fritz" Nordengren Digital Storyteller
F.R.  "Fritz" Nordengren